In the Holy Trinity Cathedral there is a memorial which had a very odd past and is connected to a violent episode of Caribbean history. The walls of the church (consecrated in 1823) are covered with marble monuments to the great Protestant families of the island, some of whom are interred in Lapeyrouse Cemetery, in Port-of Spain, in a section marked off in 1823 for them. The monument is to Major General Thomas Dundas, a Scotsman who joined the British Army in 1766 and became a MP in 1771.
He was a veteran of the American war of Independence and served under the infamous Benedict Arnold (whose name is now synonymous with treachery) and Lord Cornwallis who was a potent commander. Although he was made a POW by the revolutionaries he was still promoted to the rank of Colonel in 1782 and two years later, married the daughter of an earl. The 1790s were a turbulent time in the West Indies, which saw the Royal Navy pitted against the French and Spanish. Indeed in 1797 Trinidad was seized as a prize, and Tobago changed hands many times. British forces under John Jervis captured Guadelope and Dundas left in charge as its governor. That was to be a fatal appointment since it ultimately put the decorated English officer in direct conflict with a bloodthirsty Frenchman.
Hughes (1762-1826) was the son of French gentry but was imbued with firebrand republican ideals. Originally settled in Sainte Domingue (Haiti), he was displaced by the Haitian revolution but with the support of the Jacobin Club (instigators of the French Revolution which saw the beheading of the monarchy and rise of the republic) was appointed governor of Guadeloupe in 1794 where he wholeheartedly proclaimed the emancipation of the island’s slaves in accordance with the ordinances of Republique Francais. After a few months in the post, Hughes was routed by the British under Major General Dundas. An account of the capture runs thus:
“The march began at 5 o’clock on the morning of the 12th, and such was the simultaneousness of the manoeuvres and impetuosity of the attack that Fort Fleur d’Epée, Hog Island, and Fort Louis were captured with the trifling loss of 54 English killed and wounded, while the loss of the French amounted to 250.”
Dundas was not long to enjoy this status since a current report of the period recounted:
“On the evening of the 3rd of June, the lamented governor of Guadaloupe, General Thomas Dundas, died from yellow fever, after only three days’ illness. By his death, the West Indian army suffered an irreparable loss, and the service of one of its brightest ornaments; amiable both in his public and private life, brave and generous, possessed of that true courage which never exceeds the bounds of humanity, he justly gained the love of the army, and fell lamented by all who knew him. On the following day, he was interred with military honours, on one of the highest batteries of Fort Matilda, which from that circumstance was called Dundas’s battery, and “a stone with a suitable inscription was placed over his remains,” and the command of the fort devolved on Lieut-Colonel Blundell, 44th Regiment. In a letter to Mr Dundas received at the Horse Guards, Aug 12, 1994, from Sir Charles Grey, (dated Guadaloupe June 11, 1794,) is the following passage:
“In him. His Majesty and the country lost one of their bravest and best officers, and a most worthy man. I too feel severely the loss of so able an assistant on this arduous service, and a valuable friend ever to be lamented,”
A short time later, Guadeloupe was recaptured by Hughes who took a horrifying revenge on the French Royalist families of the island who had supported the British. The men were shot or else fed to La Guillotine, and the women gang raped and sold as sex slaves. Dundas though dead, was still deep in the grudges of his French adversary. According to the proclamation Hughes issued “That the body of Thomas Dundas, interred in Guadeloupe, shall be taken up and given as prey to the birds of the air.” The corpse was exhumed and thrown into a river where it was attacked in a decomposing state by dogs. It is however possible that what was left of his remains had been retrieved and cremated and sealed in a marble Regency urn. Next week, we will end this remarkable tale with the discovery of the urn in the most unlikely of places and its proper veneration.